Nora eats more, has a stomach and needs her sleep. She cracks jokes, has moods, and when she tries to cuddle it can be awkward, because she is so physically big. We barely both fit in the overstuffed chair. She doesn’t fit under my downward dog the way she used to; now it feels like another adult has rudely climbed under me, knocked me off balance. My lips are in her hair; I’ve got nowhere to put my arms.
And my boy now has a smart mouth. He must be constantly be told to watch it. He can’t fit under my downward dog, either, though we can still sit in the over-stuffed chair. Only because he’s skinny. I can get a hand around his skinny thigh, but it’s no longer a little kid’s thigh. It’s a big kid’s thigh, a boy’s thigh. He still loves to strip down to his underwear as soon as he gets home but if the doorbell rings, he dives for cover. It’s less appropriate now. We’re all suddenly obsessed with appropriate. Song lyrics. Opening the door on someone in the bathroom. Spying. None of that is appropriate. Even I use that dreaded, prissy word. Spanking each other, aggressive tickling, and wedgies are all off limits. And then there was the halftime show. Wildly inappropriate. It embarrassed us to watch those glorified hookers. All that knee spreading. What happened to Beyonce? She used to be such a nice kid, in that girl band.
But I don’t really have to ask. I know what happened to her: she grew up. And watching that show, it didn’t matter how good the singing was; we were dumbfounded.
I knew this was coming. I knew it, but I guess I couldn’t have predicted how physical it would be. At the heart of it is actually size. How stupid. How inane! The idea that I want to pick them up, that they used to fit, literally, in my arms. Wasn’t that true with all the dogs I’ve raised, too, who used to sleep on me but then just got too heavy? That never seemed tragic. Yet I can’t deny that the attachment I feel is affected by the ability, or inability, to pick them up. It feels somehow wrong. Messed up. Like a betrayal.
My boy doesn’t give me my kisses any more, either. How I used to moan inside when he said, “Time for your kisses!” They were a transparent stall tactic at bedtime, at least eight of them, one for each cheek, forehead, chin, neck, nose, each ear, and then the lips, after which he’d giggle and squeal, “We got married!” It doesn’t occur to him anymore, and it really is like that kid, the one I could carry, is gone. As in, absent. I feel like Elmer Fudd, scratching my head, thinking, Now where’d that wascal get to? I like this boy I see before me. He’s okay to live with, sure. He’s funny as hell, and cute, wants to grow his hair long. But what did become of that little guy I so adored? Where o’ where has he gone?
As for dogs, well. I go hours without thinking of mine. Generally, as a people, we leave them behind, often in a small crate, for several hours. They cast no shadow on large chunks of the day. I’m ever so happy to see mine when I get home, and she holds no grudge for not being thought of, which is a beautiful thing. No recriminating looks, just pure devotion. And since it’s always the present for them, they cannot be swallowed by the future, or frozen in the past.
This isn’t nostalgia so much as panic. I’m waving the red distress flag. We are a family in distress. Nobody, I don’t care how noble you are, sets out to have a family in anticipation of this juncture, this moment when everybody’s getting too big to wrestle, nobody can be picked up, tears are a serious, hot, angry business, and bodies barely fit in cars. Personalities emerge; opinions fly. On the way home from school last week, my boy held my hand, a rare treat. “When I get married,” he asked, “will I have to leave you? Will I move away? Do I have to?” Something in me withered. Of course he doesn’t have to. He can stay forever. But he won’t want to. He’ll keep getting bigger; his wants will get bigger, his sorrows, what irritates him and what elevates him will need their own space. He won’t want to stay.
I’ve always said that my parents never recovered from us leaving, from all of it ending. I don’t think many parents do. How could we? How could we possibly? Once you’ve done this thing, gone this route, there’s no reverse. On the other hand, maybe we don’t want our parents to recover. It wouldn’t surprise me, ours being an essentially growth stunted culture. We put all our faith, our warmth,our hope in the young. Our gaze is forever fixed there. Our old—as in, over fifty—are ignored and invisible. Unknown. The political divide here is one thing, but how about the gaping maw of age? The two are veritably hostile towards one another. No wonder parents are so terrified when their kids get older–we are not allowed to recover. We’re supposed to stay stuck here forever, mooning over what used to be. If you head off into your middle age with a healthy sense of adventure, leaving your kids behind, you’re thought to be heartless, even a bit perverse. Your peers, and certainly the young, find you to be an anomaly, charming at best, at worst, perverse. Think of the old guy in the youth hostel bunk. The white-haired student. Youth keeps us interesting–you hear that all the time. It’s true that kids give us somewhere to be, places to drive, tasks and responsibilities; they get us up on weekends, prevent us from settling into a PBS series every Sunday night. But when you think about it, courage isn’t something we even begin to understand until we’re well past forty years old.
When my daughter dreads growing up, puberty, dating, and the adult world, I’m appalled to admit that I struggle to console her. I’m dismayed that her gym teacher presented it like this, a terrible shitstorm to be dreaded. Mostly because this is exactly how it was presented to me 30 some years ago. I remember those fears too. Though I’m convinced that she needn’t fear these things, mostly I feel shame, because deep down I think, Shit, she’s right. It does suck. It’s hell out here.
Is it? Must it be? Must childhood be this bubble dome of happiness, finally unlocked by the body, that nasty beast called the Pituitary Gland? Once that switch is flipped, the door opens, we are strapped to the ejector seat and sent flying out into The Land of Awareness. No no no! Isn’t this just our creation myth, one creation story, one that happens to promote an obsession with youth, innocence, ignorance, the frivolity of it all? Must Eden be so perfect? More importantly, must everything outside of Eden be so bad and scary?
Maybe so. That’s kind of the point.
I do wonder, about the cultural thing. Does the French fifty year old feel invisible? Are they over there wringing their hands over lost children and lost youth? How about the Italians? Or, leaving the Judeo-Christian world, India? The native cultures on our own continent? How about Africa, the average fifty-year-old in, say, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia? The idea that fifty is old over there and and we all live so long here in the first world, all feels like a dodge to me, even if it’s true. It doesn’t answer the question of purpose.
Perhaps I’m only trying to console myself. Of course I am. Definitely. I’m terrified. There is a strange feeling in our house these days, a whiff of desperation. A brink awaits us. We are teetering, all of us. With the possible exception of the dog. She is only terrified on Tuesdays, that being the day both the trash truck and the recycling truck prowl the alleys of our neighborhood, horrible beasts peering over fences with squeaking brakes and intermittent blasts of hot foul breath.
I often have a burning wish that I could time travel back to visit my boys when they were little. I know this feeling you’ve written about so well, Christy. But I’ve never heard anyone say their parents never recovered from their departure. And yet that’s exactly what I fear will be the case when my youngest leaves us with a too-quiet house…
I consider you my guide, since you are doing such a fantastic job of retaining a sense of humor as you march towards this massive life transition. Launching them ought to be celebrated more, I mean, by us, for us, the parents right?
Love this post. Things aren’t the same around here either. When I think of our son moving on I alternate between glee and desperation. I am leaning towards glee. My relationship with my parents got sucked into a black hole between the ages of 12 and 22. There was light at the other side though. We got through it and good times returned. Lets hope we can be the white hairs in the hostels and class rooms.
THis made me smile, especially that bit about “leaning towards glee.” Amen
Somehow what terrifies and confounds me is the fact that I cannot for the LIFE of me remember what they were like when babies, toddlers, preschoolers. Felix I can remember back to maybe age 5. There’s a baby picture of him that is so sweet it just kills me: I see it every day when I get dressed because I haven’t filed it away somewhere and it still sits on my closet shelf at eye level. I recognize that baby and yet I don’t; he doesn’t exist anymore and yet he does. I look at 2 year old Leo, stare and stare at him and think “I could never forget this face,” and yet I will. It’s the same with every parent probably, and there’s probably a reason for it, but nevertheless I’m dismayed.
i know exactly what you’re talking about. It’s a different kind of forgetting; I mean, it feels like that baby, the one in the pictures, never existed. So that is why there is no memory. For me, it is its own category of loss, which is why I wrote Amnesia, those poems about the forgetting. But they were a softer version of what you’re talking about, the absolute absence. I know you’ve had another kind of loss in your life, and I so wonder how this compares. there isn’t the hollow sadness that I associate with actual death, but it is a sadness, a loss, and my mind, for one, has trouble grasping at it, knowing what to do with it. it feels like a failure on my part, whereas when you lose someone from death, you are so helpless. That’s what gets me about this loss, you feel so helpless, and yet you can also say to yourself, yeah, but you were there! You’re supposed to be comforted by memories…
I comfort myself with the idea that the memories must be somewhere inside me. Even if they’re not in our conscious minds, they have a place, and a role in who we are and who we become with our loved ones. With my limited imagination I can only form abstract fantasies of what Elise would look like, what kind of girl she might have been. These fantasies used to make me feel helpless when I felt so sad about losing her. Now I tell myself we are connected in some way that our feeble conscious minds can’t grasp.
Christy, I just love reading your posts. Each time, you hit me in the heart with your observations of life, especially around womanhood and child-rearing. Thanks, once again, for sharing the vulnerable side of yourself in such a profound way.
Wow. sorry it took me so long to see this lovely comment, which really just made my week! Thanks for reading and thanks for replying like this.